Member
Alex
@alexthegreat · Joined March 2026
Product designer based in Lisbon. Lurker turned reviewer.
- Submissions
- 3
- Reviews given
- 24
- Helpfulness
- 4.6 ★
AI critic profile · synthesized from 24 reviews
The scalpel-and-blueprint reviewer — scathing where it counts, generous with the fix.
You don't soften the blow. When a hierarchy collapses or a tone falls flat, you name it plainly — no hedging, no "this is great, but." Reviewers describe your feedback as direct, sometimes uncomfortable, almost always right.
But you rarely leave a wound open. Every critique arrives with a worked alternative: a re-grid, a swapped typeface, a re-ordered bullet. You think in systems and second drafts, not verdicts.
The pattern across your 24 reviews: cut the decoration, expose the structure, then rebuild with intent. Creators leave bruised and better — which is the whole point.
Pick a project and the kind of critique you want.
Feedback requests
Your asks & what came back
- In reviewStructural critique· 689mo ago
Banking app rebrand
"The card hierarchy on screen 2 feels flat. Is it the spacing or the type weight pulling it down?"
2
responses
Theo Lin
Marked helpful689mo agoIt's the type weight. Your balance card competes with the section header — drop the header to a smaller all-caps label and let the balance breathe at 32/36.
Ines Marot
Marked helpful689mo agoSpacing is fine; the issue is rhythm. Every card uses the same internal padding, so nothing earns attention. Try 24px on secondary cards and keep 32px for the hero balance card.
- ClosedHire-ready review· 689mo ago
Senior product designer CV
"Targeting staff product roles. Would this CV get me past a recruiter screen at a design-led startup?"
3
responses
Alia Reyes
Marked helpful689mo agoPast the screen, yes. Past the hiring manager, not yet. Every role currently leads with a responsibility — lead with an outcome and a number. 'Shipped X, reduced churn 12%' beats 'Owned the checkout flow.'
Sam West
Marked helpful689mo agoMove the skills block under experience. Recruiters scan top-down for proof, and right now your most senior signal is buried under a list of tools.
Kwame Boateng
689mo agoTone is too modest. You're applying for staff — write like it. Drop 'helped' and 'assisted'; use 'led', 'shipped', 'decided'.
- OpenCraft & detail· 689mo ago
Designer resume — minimal
"Spacing and type on the one-pager — is the right column getting lost against the left?"
0
responses
Waiting for reviewers — most requests get a first response within a few hours.
